I have already posted my review for The Body Finder and Hush, Hush and for those who had a chance to check them out, I think it's pretty clear which book I'm going to choose. But if you haven't, my pick is... The Body Finder!
In the end, it all came down to the romance between the two main characters, which was a big theme in both books. Violet and Jay made me go "awww" many times and these two characters were a joy to read about. I was disturbed in all the right places in TBF--the villain really creeped me out. While with Nora, well, it was her inexplicable attraction to Patch and their overall relationship that was creepy and disturbing (see my review of HH for reasons why). In some parts I even wanted to scream at Nora for all her silly actions and decisions.
Anyway, I had a lot of fun and enjoyed being a judge in this battle. Do let me know if you agree or disagree with my decision below if you're read the books above. I do love reading comments! :)